Our writers have experienced many shades of fatherly love—conditional, unconditional, warmly comforting, authoritarian, judgmental. From now until Father’s Day—this Sunday, June 16—we present these varied memories, which, the authors acknowledge, are tempered by the mature understanding (and sometimes empathy) that their life experience has brought them.

dad poring over bookJohannes Gaertner, joyful at his daughter’s gift.


“I know that my father loved me,

but it was in the manner of an earlier age.”

I remember my childhood with my father as a sequence of teachable moments. He was a beloved professor of art history, and “teaching” was simply his permanent personality. All of his love and affection was conveyed through his unquenchable desire to impart knowledge and—I suspect now in hindsight—to validate his presence to himself and others.

The teachable moments could have comical results. I was taken to art museums as far back as I can remember, and I loved to wander the galleries while holding his hand and listening to marvelous stories about what we were seeing. While still unable to distinguish between a Titian and a Tintoretto or tell a Monet from a Manet, I could draw the kind of conclusions that led me to equate the long armored feet of medieval knights with Catholicism—which, Papa explained, was the religion of that age. At one of my parents’ cocktail parties I came up to a very pretty woman—I imagine that I was under 7 at the time—and admired her narrow feet with the declaration that she must be Catholic. Since her family were staunch Episcopalians, this was met with gales of laughter and “Quiet, please, Susanna is speaking to her elders.”

In 1936, Johannes Alexander Gaertner left his native Germany to avoid the draft. He went to Lima, Peru, where he intended to spend a year . . . and it became 10. In 1941 he met and married my mother; they came to this country just after the war. In the manner of Einstein, Nabokov, and other émigré eggheads, my father obtained a position at Lafayette College—at that time an all-male bastion of engineering and science. His Th.D. dissertation on Roman sarcophagi made for a natural progression from Theology to Art History. My father “became” the Humanities Department, teaching German, French, Spanish, Latin, Art Appreciation, Music Appreciation, and Painting. (No doubt I have omitted something.)

As Lafayette grew, Languages and Music peeled off and my father founded, and for decades was, the Department of Art History. Legions of his students have remembered him in testimonials, recalling both his passion for the subject matter and his lovable eccentricities (a tissue box was placed on the corner of his desk on the first day of class with the admonition that students were not to sniff and snort but to come up and get a tissue if they needed one; for some reason this has stuck in the minds of many).

As the only child of such an eminent professor, I have to withstand the impulse to berate myself for being critical of him, because it smacks of selfishness, even ingratitude. But his fathering did not include the empathy that would have made him protect me from my manic-depressive mother. I can’t in good conscience fault him for this: It wasn’t on the radar of German intelligentsia of my parents’ generation and background to consider maternal bullying and jealousy as treatable depression. Papa retreated to his attic office immediately after dinner and I was left to withstand my critical—because unhappy—mother.

I know that my father loved me, but it was in the manner of an earlier age: Children were meant to be seen and not heard, to be obedient in all things, and to follow the path prescribed by their wiser parents. I wanted to be a classical ballet dancer; my father wanted me to be a professor like him. Though I showed promise as a dancer (even gaining admittance, at age 16, to a summer program at the Joffrey), this was never up for discussion.

father and daughterSusanna and Johannes Gaertner.

We had an easy if formal rapport, my father and I.  But after those museum trips in my youth, we were never again a father-daughter duo—except at Christmastime in 1989, when I surprised him with a book of his own writings that I had privately published from a manuscript I found where it had fallen behind a radiator in my father’s office. Bound in theologically appropriate maroon linen, Worldly Wisdom is a compendium of Papa’s pithy aperçus on all aspects of human behavior. Retitled Worldly Virtues, the little volume came out again in hardback under the Viking imprint, and then yet again as Penguin paperbacks in both American and Australian editions. (Hardcover and paperback copies still float around on Amazon.) I know that my father was just as happy as he could be, cheered up immensely in his declining years. Even my mother approved of this endeavor.

So I really had no relationship with this wonderful man after my teenage years. When I finished graduate school but turned to advertising as my occupation, I knew that Papa was disappointed. He could not understand why I would not want to teach at the university level, even though I now had the credentials to do so. And it took me decades to accept that not being an academic does not invalidate my life’s choices. As a Pilates instructor I now combine the movement and discipline that appealed to me from ballet with the teaching ability that is in my genes. I can only hope that he would finally be proud of me.

Join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Susan James March 3, 2018 at 10:19 pm

    I was a student of your father’s in the 1970s and was likely at the dinner Sharon described. I worked for him showing glass slides in his art history classes and organizing his image files. Also, I attended his Fortnightly Lectures for Ladies. He was a charming man who was knowledgeable in so many disciplines. I am grateful that you published his book for him. When I moved to Boston after Lafayette, he gave me half a dozen letters of introduction to scholars and historians there. I enjoyed reading your article. Thank you. Susan James

  • bill firschein AIA December 23, 2017 at 8:00 pm

    i taught at the art department at lafayette in 1976 when gaertner was there, in fact i was his hire. no one mentioned his interest in anthroposophy. this is a spiritual side of him that his daughter should have known about because this is what shaped his personality. i attended a several such study sessions at his home.

  • Susanna Gaertner May 18, 2015 at 6:19 pm

    Hello Sharon, so good to hear these words…I am in turn honored to read this effusive testimony from one of Papa’s former students. I am currently working on a project that I’d like to have your opinion on.
    Would you please contact me directly?
    831.461.0668 (CA)

  • Sharon Fastow April 13, 2015 at 9:34 pm

    Dr. Gaertner and his wife were cherished and honored members of the Lafayette College community. He was retired but still very active when my husband and I were students in the late 1970s. We were so honored to be invited to dinner at their house with some other students, where we were treated to old world manners. Dr. Gaertner was the epitome of a scholar, loving knowledge for its own sake. His wife was very gracious and kind. We still speak fondly of them to our family and friends. I was so excited to see the book his daughter published and I ordered it right away.

  • Laura Ness June 14, 2013 at 3:34 pm

    Truly beautifully done!! So artfully written. Papa definitely would approve, and would probably be so proud of you for all the you do and contribute to the world. no doubt, he would shed a tear knowing how he failed to protect you from your Mother, who probably had him so miserable, it was all he could do to keep himself from throwing dishes…

  • Kathryn Tobisch June 13, 2013 at 10:25 pm

    Reflecting on the garden of her childhood, Susanna writes insightfully in this gentle, loving tribute to her beloved father, Johannes Gaertner, based on memories which contribute to his living legacy. In these written words, we find pain artistically transformed by life into poignant beauty.